"PJ and Alex became an influential duo, and paved the way to co-host in audio. Reply All investigations were incredibly memorable, often silly but always enlightening. It seemed like episodes were dares to each other to see how far they could go."

- Audrey Mardavich, Radiotopia from PRX

Reply All treated the internet not as a novelty or menace but as a deeply human space—absurd, profound, and often profoundly broken. With restless curiosity and a flair for narrative twists, it explored digital culture through stories that veered from the bizarre to the deeply personal, always anchored by the chemistry between its hosts. At its best, the show captured the tangled emotional logic of online life with insight and irreverence, turning tech journalism into something expansive and alive. Though its run ended in controversy, Reply All remains a landmark: a podcast that made the internet feel strange, and strangely beautiful.